Created to seem fairly demanding at default with a seemingly strong taste for routines. This is a character that for sure knows how she wants things. I will still argue that his way of fulfilling duties is more SiTe-machine-like than TeSi-adminstrative-like, and therefore making him Tertiary Fi and Inferior Ne an ISTJ. It's possible that his lack of emotions about his wife's death and the motivation behind his accused murder (together with Ethel) is the effect of an Inferior Fi. Since he's not a well-developed character, it's hard to define if whether or not he could be ESTJ. He is seemingly very detached from emotions, in the way that he keeps performing his tasks even after his wife died, which is very SiTe-like of him. We don't really see much except for an extremely duty-based person when reading about him. In theory he could also be INTJ, with a strong Ni, but I definitely argue for him being an Inferior Fi over Inferior Se.Ī rather colorless character. We shouldn't rule out that he could be, let's say an ISTP with a Tertiary Ni, however, ENTJ is a highly suitable type for general, like MacArthur was. Fact is, he's the only one becoming that apathic about it, which could be the effect of an Ni-conclusion. I believe the most common type of MacArthur is some sort of xSTJ, however, I'm going for an Auxiliary Ni, mostly because of his prediction of what is supposed to happen on the island. Normally a person would have developed a majority of their functions to a near full level, which can create trouble when typing the function order. The problem with a character such as MacArthur is his age. The reason behind Te-dom is very much a guess, but I believe the death of his wife's lover was an effect of his Te, a need to control. However she is some kind of Fe-user, definitely.Īlso one of those characters with little to no development. I can't really define why I believe Si-dom, it just felt more likely than Fe-dom. This typing is highly based upon sterotypes, as the maid-character often is xSFJ of some kind. It's highly possible he is an Fe user, since he's an extremely social person. I believe that's an effect of his Ti, processing that in a cold-fact-manner, rather than from personal inner values and morale. I first went for ESFP, but I argue ESTP because of his outwardly carelessness considering the deaths of John and Lucy Combes. The tricky detail with Marston is his Auxiliary, respectively Tertiary functions. It's especially well noticed right before he dies, as he celebrates the accusations as "an exciting adventure". He lives for the here and now and is in constant search for the next adrenaline kick. This character is barely introduced before he's killed off, however we can pick up an easy Se-dom. Anyway, I find the characters of this book to be fantastically created and I believe they all have a type within the MBTI spectrum, even the characters that are killed off first. I have re-checked in with the book for this typing session, but it's possible I have made mistakes in that way. However, I have not read the book since then, but seen a couple of movie versions. I am extremely interested in Agatha Christie's masterpiece, "And Then There Were None", and have been since I read it seven years ago. This post will contain spoilers, so don't read it if you're interested in reading the book, but haven't so far. Hello, I'm pretty new to this forum! So correct any possible mistakes I may have done in the process of creating this thread.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |